October 18, 2004

The Reality-Based Community

filed under: Hey, What's The Big Idea

What's been most amazing and frustrating about amateur political blogging is watching the constant interplay between reality and reality-as-received-by-the-public. Because never the twain shall meet.

I'm not even going to post links to supporting materials here, so this is less blogging and more ranting and/or cleaning house in the muddled confines of my brain.

Here are some things that are true: the administration used 9/11 as an excuse to wage a war of choice which has been a pet idea of the neoconservative movement for a long time. WMDs were the most publicly palatable rationalization, and the easiest scare tactic. We are a nation massively in debt with no sign of improvement but instead a steepening slope. We are not safe from terrorism, and the odds of a nuclear terrorist attack, while still probably pretty long, are better than they were three years ago.

The guiding principle of the current administration is as simple as this: weaken or eliminate the government's ability to cost Businesses money in any way or for any purpose; when possible, create new opportunities for Businesses to profit. This is done not purely out of greed, but out of a soul-deep belief that this represents the Dream of America properly realized.

There is a concerted, national effort afoot to pervert the electoral process by suppressing voter turnout, jerrymandering congressional districts, keeping democratic/minority/urban voters off the rolls and away from the polls, and possibly outright fraud with an insecure, unverifiable electronic ballot (see: Deibold) and rabid partisans holding the reins of oversight in key states (see: Florida).

The news media is an entertainment industry.

The vast majority of the country (myself sporadically included) lives in a mass media created bubble which bears little or no resemblence to reality as it is actually lived and experienced. The force of psychological inertia is so massive that it took an event like 9/11 to get the vast complacent horde to briefly reconsidering the paradigm, only to relapse into semi-catatonia (myself included).

Electoral politics has become indistinguishable from mass marketing.

We are used to believing that history is something that happened, not something that's happening. McCarthyism, fascism, massive political upheaval, the perversion of entire systems of governance - all things that once happened and that we now safely reflect on. Meanwhile, history of a kind that will be discussed for the remainder of the life of America is happening all around us.

The race for the Presidency remains too close to call.

All of these things are true.

None of the above is written from a position of despair. I'm just trying to catalog and sort and process. And since I'm trying to get a glimpse of a larger, vital reality but I'm doing it 99% through the screen of a computer, I've got some wicked cognitive dissonance going on.

Thanks for listening.

Posted by rjt at October 18, 2004 12:34 PM
Comments

Ok, you asked for it: I am just cynical enough to believe that the state of affairs which you have (eloquently) described has in fact been the status quo of the world since the birth of the modern nation/state almost 500 years ago. The main difference between then and now is the reason for the disconnection between the general public's perceptions and reality. In the past, I would argue that the disconnection was caused by a lack of information, due to the severe time lag in actually finding out that something had happened until there was nothing that could be done about it. Today, however, the disconnection is caused, not by a lack of information, but by an overload of information. The vast amount of information with which we are continually bombarded either (i) makes it difficult, if not impossible, to figure out what's going on, even for those who are desperately trying to do so or (ii) allows those who don't want to pay attention to easily avoid information that is unpleasant or not in keeping with our desired view of the world. The ultimate effect of this information overload is the same as the previous information underload: most people feel powerless to affect the events taking place around them. Not that this is news to anyone.

Posted by: Scotso the Lawbot at October 18, 2004 04:10 PM

With reference to ontologically well-grounded bloggers, check out an old voice who has returned to the fray:

http://www.williamgibsonbooks.com/blog/blog.asp

the teacher always appears at the right moment.

Posted by: frydry at October 21, 2004 03:52 PM